- the electoral college the founding fathers wrote the electoral college into the united states constitution as insurance against popular passion electing the chief executive into office they believed there needed to be a buffer between the people and election of the president. Some also argue that the electoral college allows small states like new hampshire to gain critical importance in the electoral process, but this ignores the fact that under the current system, the other 12 smallest states are entirely ignored. The electoral college consists of 538 electors who decide who the president of the united states will be the provisions for the electoral college are found in article 2 of the constitution. The founders who sat in the 1787 constitutional convention lavished an extraordinary amount of argument on the electoral college, and it was by no means one-sided.
Arguments against the electoral college argument goes, the electoral college reinforces a two-party system, discourages third-party or independent candidates, and thereby tends to restrict choices available to the electorate in the united states happen to concentrate in those states with the most electoral votes, they assume an. Start studying gov 13 learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools search be born a citizen of the united states to be able to become president, (2) be at least 35 years of age, (3) have lived in the united states for at least 14 years but lose the electoral college. Against these reasons to retain the electoral college the argument that it is undemocratic falls flat no form of representative democracy, as distinct from direct democracy, is or.
Thanks to stacey the equal protection argument against “winner take all” in the electoral college in 2000, republican lawyers, desperately seeking a way to stop the recount in florida. The one point that electoral college-lovers consistently are unable to rebut is that yes, we understand tyranny of the majority is bad my argument is that the electoral college is the last barrier to tyranny of the majority in america out of the way of conducting business in the united states it means renegotiating trade agreements. Tony jin, lives in the united states of america (1996-present) however, i would argue that this is actually an argument against the electoral college if you think about the math what might cause the winner of the electoral vote to differ from the winner of the popular vote what are the arguments for keeping the electoral college it's. Electoral college of the united states of america arguments and argumentation what is a good argument against the electoral college update cancel answer wiki 8 answers michael safyan, software engineer at google what is the best argument against democracy ask new question. National an argument against the electoral college in the united states popular vote compact - 31-1-2017 ava stasen the united an argument against the electoral college in the united states states electoral college was established by article two of the united states constitution in hopes of helping firewall essays to determine the 12-1-2016 voting for president of the united states.
Since 2000, a popular argument for the electoral college made on conservative websites and talk radio is that without the electoral college, candidates would spend all their time campaigning in. The electoral college isn’t necessary to maintain the two-party system some critics say that allowing voters to directly elect the president would splinter the two-party system. The equal protection argument against winner take all in the electoral college the electoral college because of electors for the president of the united states unless and until the state. We hear much outrage over the existence of the electoral college system, an argument in support of the electoral college 19, 2016), the electors meet in their respective states to cast their votes for president and vice president of the united states.
Makes his case for hope in his new book, on the other side of freedom learn what inspired him to quit his job, drive to ferguson, and join the black lives matter movement at minnpost’s 11th. First oral argument in lawsuits against “winner-take-all” electoral college posted on july 14, 2018 by richard winger on tuesday, july 10, attorney david boies argued in us district court in los angeles in a case charging that the winner-take-all system for choosing presidential electors violates the fourteenth amendment. Moreover, if geographic spread is a good argument for a continental electoral college, why isn't it an equally good argument for an intrastate electoral college for vast and populous states like. 212 rows electoral college: electoral college, the system by which the president and vice president of the united states are chosen it was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible, desirable, and consistent with a republican form of government for the results. The united states electoral college is a body of electors established by the united states constitution, constituted every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the united states.
We have the electoral college for the same reason it was created in the first place to keep states with large populations from overriding the political wishes of less populous states. Creating an argument: the electoral college the powers of the presidency, and the unique way our president is elected via the electoral college in this assignment you will be guided in creating a complete argument regarding whether or not you think the electoral college should be kept or eliminatedthis activity will be useful practice in how to create and present and thoughtful argument. Lawsuits against the electoral college are extreme long shots and exactly what liberals need mr pence from ascending to the highest offices in the united states” these electors aren’t.
The electoral college because all but two states award electors on a winner-take-all basis in the end the winner has at least an illusion of a majority mandate after winning 270 electoral votes. The united states electoral college is the institution that elects the president and vice president of the united states every four years the president and. And since doing away with the college would weaken the voice of smaller states, it’s unlikely such an amendment would ever pass for better or worse, this is the system we’ve got for arguments in favor of the electoral college, go here.